FREE SHIPPING FOR ORDERS OVER $100 IN THE U.S.!
BUY 2 GET 1 FREE ON ALL GAMES UNDER $15! ALWAYS!
FREE SHIPPING FOR ORDERS OVER $100 IN THE U.S.!
BUY 2 GET 1 FREE ON ALL GAMES UNDER $15! ALWAYS!
FREE SHIPPING FOR ORDERS OVER $100 IN THE U.S.!
BUY 2 GET 1 FREE ON ALL GAMES UNDER $15! ALWAYS!
-
NintendoPlayStationXboxSegaImport Games
-
Nintendo Imports
-
PlayStation Imports
Other GamesVideoTrading CardsBooks/MagazinesImport SnacksSell to UsRepairs & Mods - Log in
We use cookies and similar technologies to provide the best experience on our website.
Nintendo 64 Controller Joystick Replacement Service
$17.99
Unit price / perEstimated delivery between November 13 and November 15.
This service is for the original Nintendo 64 controller only. Any region controller will work fine for this.
We'll replace the original joystick with a brand-new replica, and you can choose between two upgrade options: GameCube-style or Hall Effect.
The GameCube-style stick offers a smoother, modern feel reminiscent of the GameCube controller. The Hall Effect stick stays truer to the original N64 experience while providing improved precision and a significantly longer lifespan.
We aim to finish all services within 5-7 business days of us receiving your items. During busy times for us, you might expect it to take up to 2 weeks for completion. Transit times not included.
After placing your order, mail your controller to:
Retro Island Gaming
ATTN: Repairs Department
87B Carleton Avenue
Islip Terrace, NY 11752
In your package, please include a piece of paper with your order number. This should be in your order confirmation email. DO NOT INCLUDE ANY CABLES/ACCESSORIES/ETC. We just need the system/controller.
If you are ordering other services from us, you are welcome to ship them in the same package to us. If you order other items in the same checkout as a repair service, those items will not ship until the service(s) are complete.
Repair Terms & Disclaimers:
We do a basic functionality check before service. If your item doesn't power on or perform its core function, we won't proceed—unless the service is meant to fix that issue.
If we find minor problems, we'll contact you. No reply within 24 hours? We'll move forward with the original service at our discretion.
For any system or controller that we do not proceed with service on, we will issue a full refund minus a $10 bench fee. Please test your items before sending them to avoid this.
After service, we re-test functionality. If anything we touched isn't working, we'll fix it.
All services come with a 100-day warranty on the parts and work we did. Damage, wear, or unrelated issues aren't covered.
📦 Mail-in orders: We're not responsible for shipping damage—please pack with care!
All products are final sale unless otherwise noted below.
- Pre-owned games and home video products include a 100-Day Warranty against defects.
- Pre-owned consoles and accessories include a 30-Day Warranty against defects.
If you experience any issues, contact us at support@retroislandny.com — we’ll work to troubleshoot, repair, or exchange your item. If none of those options are possible, store credit will be issued.
Returns for reasons other than defectiveness are only accepted within 10 days of purchase. No cash refunds under any circumstance. Customers are responsible for return shipping if the return is for any reason other than a defect.
For full details, please see our Return Policy.
$17.99
Unit price / perRecently viewed products
Contact
Phone:
(631) 650-1504Email:
Support@RetroIslandNY.comStore Hours
Sunday: 11AM-9PM
Monday: 11AM-9PM
Tuesday: CLOSED
Wednesday: 11AM-9PM
Thursday: 11AM-9PM
Friday: 11AM-9PM
Saturday: 11AM-9PM
Eastern Time Zone
Standards & Policies
© 2025,
Retro Island Gaming.Nintendo 64 Controller Joystick Replacement Service
$17.99
Unit price / perEstimated delivery between November 13 and November 15.
This service is for the original Nintendo 64 controller only. Any region controller will work fine for this.
We'll replace the original joystick with a brand-new replica, and you can choose between two upgrade options: GameCube-style or Hall Effect.
The GameCube-style stick offers a smoother, modern feel reminiscent of the GameCube controller. The Hall Effect stick stays truer to the original N64 experience while providing improved precision and a significantly longer lifespan.
We aim to finish all services within 5-7 business days of us receiving your items. During busy times for us, you might expect it to take up to 2 weeks for completion. Transit times not included.
After placing your order, mail your controller to:
Retro Island Gaming
ATTN: Repairs Department
87B Carleton Avenue
Islip Terrace, NY 11752
In your package, please include a piece of paper with your order number. This should be in your order confirmation email. DO NOT INCLUDE ANY CABLES/ACCESSORIES/ETC. We just need the system/controller.
If you are ordering other services from us, you are welcome to ship them in the same package to us. If you order other items in the same checkout as a repair service, those items will not ship until the service(s) are complete.
Repair Terms & Disclaimers:
We do a basic functionality check before service. If your item doesn't power on or perform its core function, we won't proceed—unless the service is meant to fix that issue.
If we find minor problems, we'll contact you. No reply within 24 hours? We'll move forward with the original service at our discretion.
For any system or controller that we do not proceed with service on, we will issue a full refund minus a $10 bench fee. Please test your items before sending them to avoid this.
After service, we re-test functionality. If anything we touched isn't working, we'll fix it.
All services come with a 100-day warranty on the parts and work we did. Damage, wear, or unrelated issues aren't covered.
📦 Mail-in orders: We're not responsible for shipping damage—please pack with care!