Not sure what to order? Let us do the picking! Our Mystery Boxes are a fun and easy way to score a mix of awesome products from our store — all while getting more bang for your buck. You're guaranteed to receive at least 110% of the value you pay, based on our store pricing. Plus, all items originally priced under $15 are eligible for Buy 2 Get 1 Free within the box.

We may include anything we carry — video games, Pokémon cards, anime, plushies, snacks, and more! Want to add a personal touch? Make sure to include it in the text box above! Requests may include:

• Specific video game systems (e.g. Nintendo DS, Sega Genesis, etc.)

• General value mix (more budget-friendly vs. high-end items)

• Types of items (e.g. only games & snacks, or all cards)

• Game format preferences (e.g. CIB only, cartridge only)

• No duplicate games — share your PriceCharting collection link above and we’ll cross-check your order

We're happy to pack your box with whatever fits your style and our current stock!

Important Notes:

• We do not include low-value sports games unless requested.

• Mystery Boxes are curated using current Retro Island Gaming pricing and available stock. Items may be new or pre-owned unless otherwise requested. Requests will be honored to the best of our ability based on current inventory. We do not guarantee fulfillment of every request, but we will always aim to create a fun and valuable box experience. Surprise Boxes are non-refundable and not eligible for returns, exchanges, or partial refunds, unless a pre-owned item arrives defective.